Introduction
A leading spine surgeon in California faced a major denial from a commercial payer—$32,000 was lost when a herniated disc surgery claim was rejected for “lack of medical necessity.” Despite months of failed conservative treatments, the payer refused to reimburse due to missing documentation and out-of-network status.
In February 2025, Medical Billing Wholesalers stepped in. With our comprehensive denial recovery strategy, we overturned the denial within 60 days, recovered the full claim value, and improved the provider’s documentation and claims workflows.
Client Overview
This case involved a solo practice specializing in complex spine surgeries using minimally invasive techniques.
Specialty: General Surgery Billing & Coding Services
Location: California, US
Average Case Value: $25,000–$40,000
Our Service: Denial Management Services
Challenges
The provider encountered recurring issues that contributed to lost revenue:
Lack of Supporting Documentation: Initial claims didn’t include prior treatment history or imaging.
Out-of-Network Denial Risks: Insurers applied stricter review policies for OON claims.
Unstructured Appeals Process: There was no in-house workflow to manage claim rejections.
Manual Records Handling: Documentation was scattered across systems, delaying resubmissions.
These gaps reflect why many surgical practices are re-evaluating internal billing models—read more in our insight on outsourcing medical billing services to improve collections.
Our Approach
We launched a focused intervention, combining retrospective audits, provider coordination, and payer-specific appeals documentation.
Analysis
Each challenge was matched with a corrective step:
| Challenge | Solution Implemented |
|---|---|
| Missing proof of medical necessity | Submitted full clinical timeline and PCP-attested necessity letter |
| Documentation gaps | Retrieved pre-operative imaging, PT records, and prior denial explanations |
| Out-of-network complications | Included medical urgency documentation and CMS-aligned guidelines |
| Appeals inefficiencies | Built a structured internal workflow for denial categorization and response |
| Manual records delay | Transitioned practice to a centralized digital intake process |
Results
$32,000 in previously denied revenue was recovered through a successful appeal.
50% reduction in surgical claim denials achieved post-intervention.
Appeals turnaround time improved by 65%.
Approval rate for similar procedures increased to 92%.
Manual admin time on follow-ups dropped by 40% using automation templates.
Conclusion
With Medical Billing Wholesalers’ Denial Management Services, this spine surgeon not only recovered a high-value denied claim but also improved operational efficiency across the entire billing process.
Get a Free Practice Analysis
Losing revenue to denials and documentation gaps? Partner with Medical Billing Wholesalers and get a free practice analysis to uncover missed revenue opportunities and gain actionable billing improvements.
